Skip Navigation
 
Follow:
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn YouTube GooglePlus
Share:

Home  >  Conferences & Events  >  Organizers

The review process is important for developing a strong technical program. The IEEE sponsor or the conference committee defines the review process. IEEE recommends that conferences held in cooperation with non-IEEE organizations follow IEEE review guidelines.

 

Plan the review process

You should establish a review schedule and notify authors in the Call for Papers of the important dates and processes for submitting papers. The date should be far enough in advance of the conference to allow sufficient time for reviews.

  • Set the deadline for submitting papers.
  • Develop a schedule for the review tasks, deadlines, and dependencies.
  • Decide if the review is a blind or double-blind review.
  • Select independent reviewers who are knowledgeable on the subject matter of the conference.
  • Assign appropriate reviewers to each paper.

Make sure you have enough reviewers to review all submitted papers. IEEE recommends at least two reviewers for each paper. Assign no more than 12 to 15 papers to each reviewer.

light bulbA single-blind review is one where only the reviewers are anonymous. In a double-blind review, the author and reviewers are anonymous.

 
 

top of page

 

Manage the review process

The review process is easier to manage if you keep careful records and provide frequent updates on the status.

  • Maintain a log of all submitted papers.
  • Assign papers to the appropriate reviewers.
  • Keep a record of the completed reviews and comments about the quality of the papers.
  • Provide regular updates on the status of the reviews, including which papers have been accepted or rejected.
  • Notify each author regarding whether their paper has been accepted or rejected.
  • Notify authors if there are deadlines for the final copy.
  • Choose tools to manage the review process and check for plagiarism.
 
 

top of page

 

Managing peer reviews

IEEE recommends that you use a peer-review tool to manage conference papers. A peer-review tool helps you to follow a consistent process and improves the quality of your reviews.

 
 

top of page

 

Maintain confidentiality

IEEE maintains a policy of strict confidentiality for all conference submissions. You need to notify your reviewers that they cannot disclose or make inappropriate use of the content before publication.

light bulb"The Paper Review Process: Challenges and Opportunities" (57 KB). This presentation by Michael Lightner, member, IEEE Conferences Committee, is from the 2011 Panel of Conference Organizers (POCO).

 
 

top of page

 

Who do you talk to at IEEE?

IEEE is ready to help. If you have questions about reviewing submitted papers, please contact Conference Operations.

Do you have other questions about organizing a conference? Please contact the IEEE Meetings, Conferences and Events Customer Relationship Management (CRM) team..

Do you have feedback on the information on this page?

  • Is there missing or incorrect information?
  • Do you have a tip to share?

Please send your feedback to Conference Services

 
 

top of page

 

Contact Information

IEEE Meetings, Conferences and Events Customer Relationship Management is available to assist you with any questions.

screenshot of video

Meet MCE!

E-mail ieee-mce@ieee.org with questions or concerns, or call:
Toll-Free: +1 855 340 4333 (US & Canada)
Toll: +1 732 562 3878 (worldwide)

Conference resources

Conferences provide an opportunity for technical professionals to share information and connect with each other.

conference attendee taking notes